I've been using Time Machine to backup to an external hard drive. Recently I got an error saying that TM could no longer back up to the backup volume, because it was read-only. (I assume it's read-only because something happened to the filesystem. Rebooting didn't fix the fact that the backup volume is read-only.) The error message said I should back up those TM backups, but it didn't have any link or hint about how to do so. (I can't find a way to recover the error message for any more details.)
So I've got another external hard drive, of the same size, to copy the TM backups to. Various guides online say to copy the
Backups.backupdb folder from the old drive to the new drive. Sounds simple enough. But when I try to do so:
- Dragging the folder in Finder, or using Copy and Paste, results in the error message "The volume is the wrong format for a backup."
- I didn't ask for a backup at this point; I'm just copying files. But maybe macOS is trying to be extra-helpful here and help detect and prevent a future problem. Too bad it doesn't tell me what formats are acceptable or unacceptable.
- The destination volume is APFS, which is the only format that Disk Utility currently offers for creating volumes.
- The old backup volume is HFS. Surely it's not a problem to copy files from HFS to APFS? Is it a problem to migrate backups from HFS to APFS? If so, how am I supposed to migrate my TM backup using a recent version of macOS?
- Is there a way to create an HFS volume on my destination drive, in Ventura 13.4? Again, the only format options offered by Disk Utility are variants of APFS.
- Given that HFS is old and HFS+ has been standard for a long time, someone could reasonably ask whether my source drive is actually HFS+. All I can say is that diskutil reports
Apple_HFS, Disk Utility says "HFS Case-sensitive Not Journaled", and
hfs. Whether these labels are inclusive of HFS+, I don't know.
- Surely "The volume is the wrong format for a backup" isn't referring to the old TM backup volume -- TM has been backing up to it fine until a couple of days ago.
- However ... I did update the OS to Ventura 13.4 a couple of days ago. Is it possible that this update dropped TM support for HFS, and didn't provide a warning or a migration path? I'm not sure which came first, the update or the "backup volume is read-only" problem.
- In case anybody asks about turning off "Ignore ownership" on this volume, which is something you're supposed to do before copying the backup to a new drive: The Finder "Get info" dialog doesn't have a checkbox for this for the destination drive (and no indication of why not). I worked around this using
sudo diskutil enableOwnership disk5s2, which is the destination volume. It responded
File system user/group ownership enabled, so that was apparently successful, but it still won't let me copy the
Backup.backupdbfolder to that volume.
- In case it helps, I'm running Disk Utility's "First Aid" process on the old backup drive. No errors reported yet, still checking catalog file.
- There are conflicting rumors that it is impossible, or possible, to continue TM backups from an HFS volume to an APFS volume. Can anyone confirm whether this alleged FS type incompatibility is the cause of my being able to copy backup files from one drive to another?