A bunch of files behave odd in Finder.

  • I cannot not tag, rename, or open them.
  • Opening their info dialog shows everything greyed out, no interactions possible.

How did I get into the problem

  • I did some heavy multi-stage processing of hundreds of PNG files.
  • In between I duplicated a whole folder (and the files in it) to then process the files through the next stage. And tagged the files with the processing they received.
  • As such I kept all intermediary stages in folders. And each file grew by a tag per each processing stage to document what was done on it specifically (they got different treatment).
  • Should I mess up along the way, I could always go back phase by phase due to my incremental folder backups.
  • Thank to APFS being a copy-on-write system that folder duplication worked ultra fast.
  • But along the duplications and tagging something must have went wrong. In the final folder some of the files showed the odd behavior described above.


  • Checked unix file permissions, owner, etc.
  • Compared every attribute by mdls between one of the broken files vs. one of the working files.
  • Also compared if some of the exotic Mac filesystem flags may have been set differently with GetFileInfo -a plus the respective attribute letter, such as locked or inited. No luck either. Found no anomalies whatsoever.
  • Relaunching Finder or restarting the Mac didn't help either.

What can be the reason for this odd behavior?

1 Answer 1


File in Finder cannot be renamed tagged opened due to bad creation date

Reason: The Creation Date of those files was broken/invalid

After much investigation I had finally found the reason

  • All the files that showed these strange symptoms had two things in common:
  • A common Finder tag which I assigned them in a massive batch assignment (500 files or more at once).
  • They all had a Creation Date of 1984-02-24 (aka January 24th, 1984) the birth date of the Macintosh.
    • This is the fallback date if the creation date is 0 or NULL or otherwise invalid I assume.
    • So during the batch assignment of tags something broke and left the file dates in a bad state.

How to fix these broken files

  • If the creation dates don't matter to you, just set them to the same as the modification date.
    • By your tool of choice, e.g.:
      • A Better Finder Attributes
      • SetFile -d "$(GetFileInfo -m "broken-file.ext")" broken-file.ext
    • Or by a gratis and builtin function of Finder:
      • You can simply zip the file(s)s with Finder's integrated ZIP command.
      • Right-click file(s) > Compress.
      • All macOS metadata is preserved (Finder Tags, Spotlight Comment, dates, permissions, etc).
      • And when unzipping the file plus all metadata is restored and the broken/invalid creation dates are fixed automatically.
  • In my case preserving the creation dates mattered to understand the image file genesis.
    • But due to having worked with incremental backups, I could restore them from one of the intermediary folder. And just tag them again.
    • And this time I left the Finder window in front, until all tags updated (can take some 20-60 seconds when tagging hundreds/thousands of files) not to mess it up again. I guess having done something else in Finder while the tagging process was in process caused the mess up in the first place.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .