I have two Apple IDs. One is with a gmail.com address and the other is with an icloud.com address. I have been using all of Apple's online/cloud/store services since they were released and have no idea how I ended up with two over time, but there is a clear distinction:

The icloud.com one has my iCloud - I sync iMessages in iCloud, have an iCloud drive, sync contacts, and use find my devices all on this account. I do not use iCloud backups or any sort of cloud photo features. I do not actually use my iCloud/.Mac email address.

The gmail.com one is logged into all the stores (music back in the day when I bought tracks individually, app stores, iBooks, etc).

I have a Mac, iPhone, iPad, and watch. I want to once and for all just have one login for everything Apple.

My thought is that since applications and other purchases cannot be transferred, I just need to transfer all my iCloud-synced information to the gmail.com Apple ID, then I can close or stop using the icloud.com Apple ID. I don't think I can go the other way since app purchases cannot be moved between accounts. Is this correct?

How do I go about doing this? Is it as simple as signing out of my iCloud account on one device, signing in on another, and repeating on each device, or will that potentially result in data loss or problems? What annoyances will I have to work around?

Thanks for your help.

1 Answer 1


As no-one has picked up on this yet, I'm gonna say "It's a toughie!"

I had my first .mac account in the 90's, a private email address for iTunes since 2001 [which I consider my primary account, as it's still my 'real' email address] & me.com [now also icloud.com] since the iPhone & the App Store started.
I have never found any way to successfully merge these identities.
me.com has all my 'cloud sync' stuff, iTunes has all my apps. I have them both set to the same password so I don't have to think too hard about it… & let it go at that.

  • 1
    Same here. Works rather well (even with two distinct passwords).
    – nohillside
    Commented May 6, 2020 at 7:46
  • Ditto - but I thought the mac.com addresses cam after itunes (which is why my itunes is not an Apple email)
    – mmmmmm
    Commented Sep 13, 2021 at 20:21
  • @mmmmmm - You're right. I was guessing based on where I worked at the time. Wikipedia says iTools 2000, .Mac 2002 [which does not fit my memory of the timeline at all] then iTunes 2001. I just tracked my .mac address back to 2004, so obviously I didn't yet have it when first signing up to iTunes, hence that being my own domain name instead.
    – Tetsujin
    Commented Sep 14, 2021 at 7:55

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .