I have several external drives, all of which work fine, but recently purchased and backed up to a new drive (Samsung T5) which always fails to eject cleanly. Whenever I try to eject it, I'm asked:

“Drive” is a volume on a disk that has 2 volumes. Do you want to eject “ Drive” only, or both volumes?

To eject both, click Eject All, or hold down the Option key while ejecting.

To eject only “Drive,” click Eject, or hold down the Control key while ejecting.

Unless I choose Eject All, the drive stays around, so I choose Eject All. But then I get a message that says "Drive - Data" was not ejected because it was in use, and I have to Force Eject to finally eject it. When I then unplug the drive I get a warning that doing so might have caused problems.

There's nothing that I know of that's actually using the drive when I do this, and no damage seems to be done.

Why won't my Samsung T5 eject cleanly?

The drive is formatted APFS/GUID, unencrypted and is a bootable clone with FileVault enabled (though it behaved this way before FV was enabled too, and before anything was backed up to it.)

  • Note that I'd VERY much like to avoid starting from scratch with the drive. The initial backup and enabling of FV takes a very long time!
    – orome
    Commented Dec 13, 2019 at 21:49
  • I'm exploring this as a fix; it's looking promising.
    – orome
    Commented Dec 16, 2019 at 17:32
  • This problem comes up on my T5 because I have my Photos library stored on it and VideoConversionService is always running rampant, and Backblaze is sometimes quietly scanning files.
    – Sol
    Commented Dec 18, 2019 at 0:40

2 Answers 2


This issue is generally caused by a background process that is taking a (very) long time to complete.

In my case it was Spotlight indexing, which I don't need for the drive in question. So after confirming that it the culprit was indeed Spotlight and terminating it, I simply disabled Spotlight indexing for the drive, and now I am able to eject cleanly. Similar instructions apply for identifying and terminating whatever process is the cause generally.

  • Note that I still get the message: “Drive” is a volume on a disk that has 2 volumes. Do you want to eject “ Drive” only, or both volumes?; but that's another question.
    – orome
    Commented Dec 18, 2019 at 15:49

Logging out and logging back in should allow you to eject any drive that does not host the operating system currently in use.

As to why, finder is often the culprit.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .