3

My MacBook Pro (2017, 15 inch, Touch Bar) is not charging under heavy load (full load on CPU + GPU when working with 3D programs in VM):

enter image description here

When I close the processes that consume system resources, it starts charging normally again. Is it a normal behavior?

2 Answers 2

5

This behaviour is perfectly normal.

On all of Apple's Intel-based laptops, the battery-pack is the power source 100% of the time, even when connected to a charging supply. The battery-pack is comprised of two circuits of cells, each circuit is capable of providing the maximum current demand of the laptop whilst the other circuit gets a recharge, with the two circuits changing roles every few minutes.

Whilst your MacBook Pro shipped with an 87W charger, the actual maximum draw of the computer itself is 121W - display on, WiFi/BT enabled and communicating, CPU & GPU both at full workload. Under that level of power use, the battery is having more power go out than what is coming in, so you will lose charge under maximum load even when connected to a charge source, albeit at a slower rate than if it were running on battery alone.

1
  • Okay then, nothing to worry about. Thanks for the detailed explanation. Sep 17, 2019 at 10:32
2

Yes, that sounds normal.

The cable is only designed to supply so much then the computer takes whatever else it needs from the battery.

If the battery is too low and the demand high it will limit the cpu performance...

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .