On the first of January every year, I move the previous year's mails from INBOX, to 'all', which is an actual 'physical' folder in Mail.app - in other words, off the server and onto my Mac. I do this by selecting the last message of 31 December, and then scrolling to the 1 January of the previous year, and holding down SHIFT whilst I select that message. I then right-click on the selected mails, and choose 'move to' and 'all'.

In 2018, there are over 13,000 messages, so when I perform the above operation, I wait for a little while. They appear to have vanished from INBOX, which is good. I click on ‘Sent’, intending to do the same with 2018’s messages in there. But if I switch back to INBOX, hey presto – nothing has been moved. Worse, if I go and look in ‘all’, I see copies of the messages that I thought I had moved. If I did it ten times, there would be ten copies of those e-mails.

I know that there is also a ‘copy’ option on the contextual menu, but I do not click on that. I click on ‘move’.

Why are my messages not moving?

  • Are you using iCloud and the messages are being replaced? – Solar Mike Jan 11 at 10:35
  • No, iCloud is not active. – Darren Matheson Jan 11 at 11:00

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.