2

"You have a new memory"...
No I don't, I have the same dodgy recollection of the past that I always did.
"What was for dinner yesterday?"... not a clue unless I look at the dribbles down my shirt.

Anyway, Photos seems to think I ought to be reminded of people & places I haven't recalled in years & announces out of the blue, "You have a new memory"...

I click on it & I'm greeted with an image from 2007, of my partner.
Well, honestly I do remember who she is, I'm not that bad - in fact I just saw her, seconds ago, she's still fine...

...but when did Photos turn into Facebook & decide to prompt me with this kind of thing?

More importantly, how do I switch it off?
Not just the notification, I want it to simply not do that.
I'm not still at school, taking selfies & pictures of my food every day, I don't want my professional environment besmirched by 'social media'-type actions.

Plus points for how it's actually doing this. Does it just flip a coin & present me with some random picture, or is it more insidious?
I don't have any photos stored or shared on iCloud.

[Facebook, you'll be happy to know, I dissuaded from this kind of thing years ago. People still use it to try to contact me... eventually they'll learn ;-)

btw, question is a somewhat flippant rant [look up Victor Meldrew, or One Foot in the Grave], answer is still important ;)

In a more serious tone - how does this sit with GDPR?
I didn't opt-in to this.

  • 2
    This is a good question just not written properly. – JBis May 29 '18 at 20:53
2

Hum... Even though I think your question is actually not a real one - you seems to know that Apple tried to implement a Facebook-like feature and made it impossible (or really hard) to disable, a piece of answer is that Photos is not designed (in my opinion) for a professional use.

Photos is intended to store photos of your family, your friends, your trips and holidays or other annoying every day's stuff like that. Every feature is design in this purpose: moments, collections, faces, locations as well as shared albums and ... memories!

I'm afraid you only have few solutions available including turning of memories notifications you mentioned (and never tap the memories album again). If you don't want [your] professional environment besmirched by 'social media'-type actions you may have to choose a different photo app to separated your professional and private life.

Concerning the algorithms behind memories, it is obviously based on similarly between groups of photos (location, date, people...). From my personal experience 2 différents types of memories are highlighted by the App:

  • Regular memories that gather photos from a recent event (a trip, a week-end, a party). They are usually pushed froward few weeks after the event ends.
  • Special memories that are usually highlighted many month (sometimes years) after the event ends. Such memories could contain only photos of a specific person (the memory titles "[Person X] over the years", "[Person X] birthday", [Person X]'s Home) or photos taken a specific amount of time ago (a have a "5 years ago" one, here are some other examples: "last Winter", "On this Day", "Chrismas day", "Halloween" and even "Best of Last Week/Mounth/Year").

I guess that you dislike this second category. This is quite intrusive I reckon but Photos App IS a social App since Apple designed to encourage photo sharing and viewing between family and friends rather than for professional use.

  • The question is a real one. I don't use Photos for professional purposes, only for 'happy-snaps' from my phone. My point is that, even though I have as much of the 'social' aspect of it switched off as possible, it still decides what it's going to do. I find that too 1984. – Tetsujin May 30 '18 at 6:34
  • Sure, in a perfect world Apple would allow user to toggle off these kinds of features. By the way Google provides the same feature in Google Photos and unlike Apple it is possible to disable that thing. However it is not in Apple's philosophy to be that permissive for the user sometimes. – Louis Lac May 30 '18 at 11:23
1

I love the idea of Photos automatically creating an album of Mr Boots, so I don't have to. I don't love a popup notification (esp. with audio ding) disrupting my hyper-focused state of productivity. So... I clicked the gears icon (System Preferences) >> Notifications >> Scrolled down to Photos >> Unchecked Everything and changed alert style to None enter image description here

0

You don't have to turn off all Photos notifications if you just want to stop the Memories notification... just go to:

Photos App/Photos Menu/Preferences/Show Memories Notification checkbox.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .