3

We all know that notification 'Drive X was not ejected properly'. I have a laptop, which I use regularly at my desk with monitor etc, as well as on the go. I want to be able to back up my data to an external drive, so I've got a 1 TB drive connected via a USB hub alongside my mouse an keyboard.

It's a real pain trying to remember to eject the disk before I unplug the laptop to take it somewhere. Especially when I'm in a hurry I often forget. I've seen that notification countless times when pulling out thumb drives but nothing ever happened so I stopped taking it seriously.

That is, until my backup drive got corrupted. It's now in a state where disk utility consistently fails to reformat it and time machine can't write to it. I have two other USB devices this has happened on, but they were fairly old ones I used infrequently so I assumed something else had made them fail.

Why does OS X require users to be so careful ejecting drives? Both Windows and Ubuntu (the other two OS's I've used) seem to handle this fine. Is there a way that I can have this drive consistently connected so that backups happen automatically, but that I don't have to worry about the drive being damaged?

marked as duplicate by Allan, nohillside Apr 17 '18 at 14:38

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • howtogeek.com/172931/… – Denis Rasulev Apr 17 '18 at 6:10
  • Interesting. Funny that one didn't come up in my googling. So there's no way to safely remove a USB drive except ejecting? – KFox Apr 17 '18 at 6:43
2

Actually, the assumption behind your question is incorrect.

While other operating systems may manage the ejection of external drives differently (to some degree), they still require users to eject or safely remove them prior to physically unplugging them while the computer is still powered up.

The reason why this is important is that any computer (regardless of OS) can initiate a read or write sequence while it's powered up. It's important to note that not all read/write sequences are initiated by the user. Often they're initiated by the OS or other software, so even though you may think it's safe to remove that drive, it in fact may not be.

In terms of how you may be able to have this drive consistently connected so that backups happen automatically without the worry of damaging your drive, there's no 100% safe way without either ejecting the drive or fully shutting down a computer first. However, your next best bet is to ensure you close the lid of your MacBook prior to unplugging the laptop and taking it somewhere. By doing this and waiting a few moments the MacBook will go to sleep and unplugging the external drive will be safer (although not 100% safe).

0

There's no amount of damage you can do to a USB drive by removing it without ejecting it that can't be fixed by a format.

Windows has a similar removal notification, or at least used to.

I'm not doubting that there's some issue with your drive, but if it can't be resolved by a low-level format then it wasn't caused by OSX when you failed to eject it prior to removal.

  • 1
    Actually, I disagree to some extent. If the drive is a traditional hard drive (i.e. with rotating disks/platters), then it could be damaged by unplugging it while it's in the process of a read/write operation, especially if this was a regular occurrence, although the risk is certainly low. The much higher risk, as you rightly point out, is data corruption. – Monomeeth Apr 17 '18 at 7:46
  • To the best of my knowledge modern HDDs are able to to park the heads even in the case of a sudden power outage. While I wouldn't recommend testing this, in theory the sudden removal of power shouldn't result in any physical damage to the drive. – Scottmeup Apr 17 '18 at 8:17

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .