Any problem with using a newer Mac laptop to install macOS Sierra onto an external hard drive, then install into an older Mac laptop? (assuming both Macs are Sierra-capable, obviously)

Are there any issues with booting and running an older Mac from a macOS created with a newer Mac? For example, does the Sierra installer install drivers specific to the Mac on which the Sierra installer app ran?

  • I found one catch: Apple refuses to run some older macOS installers on some newer Macs. – Basil Bourque Aug 6 '17 at 5:15

This should work fine; the installer will install all drivers needed for all supported Mac models, so you can move drives between models pretty freely.

Update: Starting with High Sierra, this is no longer supported. The OS itself will be fine, but unless you run the High Sierra installer on that computer, and with a live Internet connection, the computer's firmware may not be properly updated to support the new OS. According to Apple support article HT208020:

If you try to use a monolithic system image [equivalent to transferring an HD with the OS installed], required firmware updates will be missing from the installation. This causes the Mac to operate in an unsupported and unstable state.

See this TidBITS article for more info.

BTW, just to give you some idea of the possibilities for trouble: there was an issue with Mac OS X v10.2 (yes, long ago) where if you installed it on an iMac DV model that hadn't had its firmware updated, it did something bad to the video configuration, and the display would be blank. The display would remain blank, even if you booted back into an older version. This made it really hard to run the firmware updater and make the computer usable again. I was working in a repair shop at the time, and we had a lot of iMacs come in with this problem.

I suspect the current firmware compatibility worries have to do with compatibility with the new APFS volume format, so the worst that should happen is that an un-updated Mac won't be able to boot from a High Sierra volume in APFS format. Probably. Maybe. No promises, though.


You should install HighSierra on that older computer. You may use the installer file from any computer, since that download is mac unspecific.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .