3

I've been trying to buy some dongles for my new MBP 2017, but as I've been reading lots of reviews and product descriptions, it seems like some dongles that work with MBP 2016 does not with the 2017 version. What's going on?

Also any insight on why we can't daisy chain the dongles (e.g. Thunderbolt 3 -> Mini Displayport -> VGA/HDMI)? I have lots of Mini Displayport dongles I would still like to use.

For example look at the product description in these two links:

  1. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01C316EIK

    THUNDERBOLT 3 PORT COMPATIBLE with the reversible USB-C connecter that connects to new computers and tablets > with Thunderbolt 3 such as the 2016 MacBook Pro (NOT 2017 iMac or MacBook)

  2. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N2ORP84

    NOTICE: the firmware of our products is updating now, please don’t connect this product to iMac 2017 and > MacBook 2017. USB TYPE C to Mini DisplayPort (Mini DP, MDP) adapter connects a computer host with a USB > Type-C port to a monitor or projector with Mini DisplayPort input, ★NOTICE★: DO NOT connect adapter(like mini > dp to DVI adapter) from other brand to USB-C to mini displayport adapter for a second signal convert, we > can't guarantee it works well.

EDIT: Found a link with as a reference for the answer: http://www.macworld.com/article/3200052/displays/apples-thunderbolt-display-doesnt-work-with-a-12-inch-macbooks-usb-c-port.html

3

You gotta love the heightened level of complexity that simplifying things down to one connector has made things. Let's sort it out....

  • USB-C is the connector type. It's the physical interface specification just as USB-A, USB-B, USB-Micro, USB-Mini are all physical connectors. It's not a USB port, nor is it a Thunderbolt port.

  • USB 3.0/3.1 is the USB specification and port type. It sets the standard for how USB will communicate on your machine. It's backward compatible with USB 2.0, 1.1, and 1.0

  • Thunderbolt 3 is the Thunderbolt specification that supplies DisplayPort, PCIe, USB 3.0 and power. It's backward compatible with Thunderbolt 2 and 1. Thunderbolt 3 utilizes the USB-C interface and Thunderbolt 1/2 utilize a mini DisplayPort interface connector.

  • Daisy Chaining - Thunderbolt can be daisy chained, while DisplayPort cannot. Usually, displays are last in the Thunderbolt chain.

As for the Macs...

  • MacBook Pros from 2016 onward have 2 or 4 Thunderbolt ports that utilize USB-C interfaces

  • MacBooks have USB 3.1 ports with DisplayPort support that utilize USB-C interfaces.

So, when you are picking your adapter, you have to determine what port you have on your machine first. Then you pick the physical inteface type that works for you.

For example if you have a MacBook, you will have a USB port with DisplayPort support on a USB-C interface. This means you can use a USB to DVI/HDMI/DisplayPort adapter or you can use a USB-C DisplayPort to DisplayPort cable. What you can't use is a Thunderbolt cable/adapter

If you have a MacBook, you have a few more options because of the inclusion of Thunderbolt.

As for the iMac... Thunderbolt is Thunderbolt. It doesn't change from MacBook to iMac to PC. A Thunderbolt adapter for the MacBook Pro will work on an iMac because, after all, an iMac is a MacBook Pro in a different form factor.

  • Ah, so you're saying the "ITANDA USB C Type to Mini DisplayPort" designed for Macbook 2016 would support: (Interface) USB-C and (Specification) USB 3.1 + DisplayPort. So would you say that the above adapter would NOT work with the new MBP 2017 USB-C Thunderbolt 3 port, because USB 3.1+DisplayPort is a different specification from Thunderbolt 3. – ahong Jul 5 '17 at 22:49
  • I can't speak to that adapter as their specs are unclear. However, if you are going from MBP to DisplayPort, get a cable, if you are going from MBP to HDMI/DVI/VGA, get an active adapter – Allan Jul 5 '17 at 23:17
  • Seems like all the adapter makers who support 2016 Macbook Pro Thunderbolt 3 are updating the "firmware" on their adapters to support the 2017 version of Thunderbolt 3. I'm not sure what's different here. It's clear to me now that the 2015 Macbook (12") USB-C connector is not actually Thunderbolt 3. – ahong Jul 5 '17 at 23:20
  • are you able to address what is going on with this "firmware" update lots of adapter manufacturers are talking about for MBP 2016 to 2017? – ahong Jul 6 '17 at 7:40

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .