Been experiencing endless issues with file sharing on Yosemite server and latest Server App (5.0.x). When a user connected to the server in the finder sidebar, it connects with SMB and they experience issues. Like read only, etc.. So, AFP is the answer... Command + K (Connect to server) and enter the server IP prefixed with afp:// works fine. However, in attempted to make it easier for the user, I would like them to use the sidebar in finder. If I turn OFF SMB for a particular share in file sharing in the server app, the share is no longer visable. Has anyone experienced the same issue? I assume the SMB only wants to work with bonjour? Can I make the default bonjour browsing use AFP?