4

EDIT: I just discovered that an Apple Music Family Plan actually requires OSX Yosemite and iOS8, which is a non-starter since we will not be upgrading past Mavericks (Yosemite caused me massive problems and I had to remove it and downgrade immediately) and my partner despises iOS later than iOS 6 and won't use it. So I guess this means I'm stuck with only an individual plan regardless.

EDIT 01.31.2016: Turns out that there is a VERY significant, but somewhat subtle, reality in dropping iTunes Match and using Apple Music instead. ALL music you add in the future, will become DRM-encoded if you ever download it from the iTunes Music Library, including your own non-DRM CD rips! Looks like the only actual "solution" is to have both iTunes Match and Apple Music. =(

I've been an iTunes Match subscriber for a couple of years, and I have my ~15,000 songs all uploaded and also local on my Mac. I don't really use it for mobile devices much at all, and primarily got it so that I could update my library (much of which was ripped from CDs long ago at 96kb to 128kb) to 256kb versions.

Now I've been playing with Apple Music during the initial free trial period and I have to admit, I like it a lot. I've been discovering music like crazy including many albums by artists I like a lot, that I had no idea were even still releasing albums (OMD anyone?? WOW!)

But now, iTunes Match wants to renew again in a few days, and I'm really unclear on if I need it or not. Info online seems to be incomplete and conjectural, since Apple Music is still so new.

What exactly will I lose if I let iTunes Match expire, given that I already have all of my library downloaded locally?

I understand (correct me if I'm wrong please) that with Apple Music, all matched music that is downloaded will have DRM. I can live with this. I also believe that any music that is not matched and instead is uploaded by Apple Music to my iCloud Library, will stay in the original format i.e. DRM-free. This is good because some of my library is music I composed myself or by other musicians that I know or work with, and I wouldn't want that stuff to suddenly be locked down.

Given this, is there actually any reason I'll regret letting iTunes Match lapse and instead signing up for an Apple Music subscription? I know the cost is significantly higher, but I'm so enjoying the music discovery process in iTunes that I'm actually thinking it's worth $15 for a family plan for myself and my partner.

3

Your understanding of the DRM is correct.

The functionality of iTunes Match is included with Apple Music, so yeah: win win.

  • So then there is nothing lost (aside from the DRM reality) by dropping iTunes Match? I won't lose any of, or have to re-upload my entire existing library? Has anyone actually done this to know that it will behave seamlessly? – Jonathan van Clute Sep 7 '15 at 20:27
  • Yes, I have done so myself; things can still go wrong however, cross your fingers :) – eethirteenzz Sep 7 '15 at 20:32
  • Indeed they can. Fortunately I have both a local and cloud backup of all my content, separate from the iCloud Music Library itself and the primary active local copy of my music library. So I believe I'm about as well covered as I can expect to be. Fingers, toes, and eyes crossed! – Jonathan van Clute Sep 7 '15 at 21:16
3

This is a nice way to ask What's the difference between iTunes Match and Apple Music?

You have yourself covered as long as you download all of your Purchased and uploaded music from Apple's servers before your subscription lapses.

  • iTunes Match was priced at $2 a month to store everything online and sync playlists, metadata and songs across multiple devices
  • Apple Music is priced at $10 a month to do everything iTunes Match did. It also adds nearly unlimited DRM downloads of the catalog, nearly unlimited streaming of the entire catalog, and reduction in advertisements of streamed content.

Going forward, do the math on which plan works best for yourself and potentially family organized group budget wise. I'm all in on the value of Apple Music. It's like the best record shops on the planet are my personal lending library and the due dates are extended for as long as I choose to pay up.

The only thing I'm not all in on is that my master iTunes Library is on an older Mac that I've totally cut off from the internet until I'm confident how my library lasts and how speedy a download of 40 GB will be should I choose to exit the plan.

  • Yep this is how I'm leaning as well. I'm thoroughly impressed with the whole discovery process of music in iTunes now. I actually just tried Spotify for the first time and frankly, I thought it sucked. I think I'm going to go ahead and let iTunes Match go. – Jonathan van Clute Sep 7 '15 at 21:15
-3

I heard recently that iTunes and Apple music is banned in other countries and is labeled as piracy. I think it's because they don't pay royalties when they sell you a song.

Some of the information contained in this post requires additional references. Please edit to add citations to reliable sources that support the assertions made here. Unsourced material may be disputed or deleted.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .