3

So, I used to have a partition with windows 8 on it. I started that partition when Windows 8 was still in Developer preview, and it worked really well for a while, and I upgraded it a few times eventually to 8.1.

Then the partition wasn't recognized anymore. I think it was after the upgrade to Yosemite (but could have been Mavericks, I don't remember).

I just this week repartitioned and formatted the computer. Now, I'm on Yosemite, and I have tried a bunch of things to get Windows 10 installed and I can't get it to work.

I tried these things:

Creating A Bootable USB Of Windows 8.1 On OS X?

Bootcamp doesn't allow me to install an ISO to a USB (because I'm pre USB), and doesn't support my windows 10 iso that I burned to a DVD (RW), because, according to BootCamp, my computer doesn't support windows 8. This is wrong for two reasons: 1, I used to have windows 8 running smoothly (more smoothly [anecdotally] than yosemite does (but this is a 6+ year old macbook, so what's to be expected?) Also, this is windows 10, why is it complaining that windows 8 isn't supported when I'm trying to do windows 10 (sure, simple mistake, but a mistake nonetheless).

I've tried various steps involving updating my info.plist file, but after I do that (which requires very specific set of steps to even get updated, bootcamp won't even work. Some sources say that this is because modifying the plist file breaks a signature, and have a seperate command to re-sign, but the re-signing steps are out of date for yosemite, so the command isn't right.

I've found other resources that recommend using dd to put the windows 10 iso (or a .img converted using hdiutil convert onto a 32 gb usb, but when I do that, while it looks fine in osx, the drive isn't recognized as formatted in any windows machine, and doesn't work to boot.

Any recommendations?

  • Comments are not for extended discussion; this conversation has been moved to chat. However, I must say the quality of the chat is excellent. Good work all in trying to clarify the question. – bmike Sep 15 '15 at 18:50
4

How to install Windows without using the BootCamp Assistant.

  1. Download and copy the Boot Camp Support Software to a flash drive. You will need this later.
  2. You need to create a "MS-DOS (FAT)" formatted partition.

    One way would be during a clean install. Use the Disk Utility to create a two partitions. The first would be "Mac OS Extended (Journaled)" for OS X and the second would be "MS-DOS (FAT)" formatted for Windows. Install OS X to the first partition. I would avoid using Core Storage.

    The second way would be to create a single "Mac OS Extended (Journaled)" partition and install OS X. Again, avoid using Core Storage. Once installed, you should be able to use the Disk Utility to shrink this partition and add a "MS-DOS (FAT)" formatted partition for Windows.

  3. Bless the Windows partition. Using the Disk Utility application, highlight the "MS-DOS (FAT)" formatted partition and click the Info button. Note the Disk Identifier. It usually is disk0s4. To install Windows, the last digit can not be greater than 4. In a Terminal application window, enter the following command.

    sudo bless --device /dev/disk0s4 --setBoot --legacy
    

    Here is assumed disk0s4 is the correct Disk Identifier.

  4. Set the active MBR partition. From a Terminal application window enter the following.

    sudo fdisk -e /dev/disk0
    flag 4
    quit
    yes
    

    Here 4 was used because it was the last digit of the Disk Identifier. Below is an example of me entering the above commands.

    Steelhead:~ davidanderson$ sudo fdisk -e /dev/disk0
    Password:
    fdisk: could not open MBR file /usr/standalone/i386/boot0: No such file or directory
    Enter 'help' for information
    fdisk: 1> flag 4
    Partition 4 marked active.
    fdisk:*1> quit
    Writing current MBR to disk.
    Device could not be accessed exclusively.
    A reboot will be needed for changes to take effect. OK? [n] yes
    Steelhead:~ davidanderson$ 
    
  5. Install Windows. Insert the Windows DVD and restart the computer. Hold down either Option key during restart. Choose the DVD when the icons appear. If you have more than one DVD icon, there may be a problem with the DVD. In this case, see the note below.

  6. After the installation of Windows is complete, insert the flash drive and install the Boot Camp Support Software.

This was done from my memory. If you have a problem, let me know.

Note: More Than One DVD Icon

When trying to boot to the Window installation, DVD you may get two DVD icons to choose from. They are usually labeled "Windows" and "EFI Boot". The correct choice is "Windows". This may lead to the following message being displayed.

       1.

       2.
Select CD-ROM Boot Type :

I found this to be true using a DVD burned from the "Windows10_InsiderPreview_x64_EN-US_10074.iso". The message has also occurred using certain Windows 7, 8 and 8.1 installation DVD's. The problem is the DVD and not with the steps given in this answer. The solution is to remove the "EFI Boot" method from the DVD or iso image. The procedure is given at “Select CD-ROM Boot Type:” error during Windows install.

  • I do have more than one DVD icon. One is "Windows" and the other is "EFI Boot"? – McKay May 25 '15 at 3:21
  • Windows is for older Macs like yours. This is a BIOS/MBR install. The EFI boot is for newer computers. This is a EFI/GPT install. Select Windows and if the install proceeds then continue. Otherwise, post a comment. – David Anderson May 25 '15 at 3:24
  • I did get Windows 10 to install using the method above specified. I did not see a message with the "Select CD-ROM Boot Type :". – McKay May 25 '15 at 17:02
  • I am now installing the Bootcamp drivers using the flash media from earlier. It originally did not install because the boot camp installer said that it only works with windows 7, but Windows then detected that it didn't install correctly, so it recommended a compatibility mode, and that appears to be working. – McKay May 25 '15 at 17:05
  • Bootcamp drivers installed successfully. Now I have a full resolution win 10 with a right mouse click. Thanks Dave. – McKay May 25 '15 at 17:17
1

Why so complicated?

Just start Windows 8.1 and then update via web or when notified for the free copy download, to Windows 10.

Forget and ignore the Boot Camp compatibility.

I have updated a MacBook Pro, Late 2008 or maybe Early 2009, without any problems from Windows 8.1 to 10.

By the way I also updated my Mac Pro, Early 2008, to Windows 10.

This machine was not even meant to be compatible for Windows 8. I simply ignored Boot Camp (installed version 3) and started updates as per the procedure above.

There are only a few keyboard keys which are disabled like brightness and loudness adjustments as well as the eject key, but this can be easily controlled from other menu items.

  • How do you expect to run Windows update when the computer does not have any version of Windows Installed? You might try reading the posted question, before supplying your answer. – David Anderson Aug 24 '15 at 22:07
  • @Ron "Then the partition wasn't recognized anymore." I lost access to my Windows 8.1 partition. I was considering reinstalling 8, but it wouldn't let me do that either. Going straight to 10 was more direct for my needs. – McKay Aug 27 '15 at 13:04
  • Did Windows 10 give you better performance than 8? – Dan Oct 21 '16 at 9:35

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .