32

I love everything about my Macook Air except its very low maximum memory (and yes I bought it with the maximum available at the time).

So I'm thinking "I know how to solder... how hard can it be?". It's not that unusual for the theoretic limit at the time a computer is manufactured to be surpassable later when modules with more memory become available.

Is the claim that the memory can't be upgraded based solely on the assumption that no one knows how to solder? Or is it massively more difficult to solder new memory into a laptop than it is to solder some simple electronics project? Are there any big difficulties other than just the need to solder the memory in place (and unsolder the old memory)?

|improve this question
  • If you have the experience with integrated circuits, then do it. Keep in mind you have to almost simultaneously heat up and supply proper level of solder to multiple points (legs). I only manged IC's with up to 6 legs and even that was a murder. – Ruskes Nov 29 '14 at 0:43
9

Yes, it is possible, and REWA Technology has done it, and demonstrates how they did it in this video: https://youtu.be/CTsEJ49LLsQ

After taking the laptop apart, you must:

  • heat up the sealing adhesive around the two camera chips
  • remove sealing adhesive with tweezers
  • apply some BGA paste flux around the RAM chip
  • blow it with a hot air gun for 30 seconds
  • take off the RAM chips
  • solder the tin to the soldering iron and flat the bonding pads
  • clean with an anti-static wipe
  • RAM chips cannot be mixed
  • blow the bonding pad with a hot air gun
  • apply some BGA paste flux to the bonding pad
  • align the RAM chip to the bonding pad
  • blow it with a hot air gun
  • solder the rest of the RAM chips to the bonding pad
  • remove the 10k resistance R2051
  • detach a 10k resistance from a broken motherboard
  • solder the detached 100k resistance to R1636
  • test both ends of the reesistance for a short circuit or missing solder
  • put the pieces of the laptop back together
|improve this answer
  • 3
    Oh, is that all? /rollseyes – tubedogg Jul 7 '17 at 2:11
  • 1
    8GB is the max due to the board design and CPU choice. OP said he already has the max apple sells, which means he already has 8GB. – bobpaul Aug 8 '17 at 15:20
27

iFixit, who is a proponent of replacing everything in your system, does not provide a guide to replace the RAM (only the entire logic board, on which the RAM is soldered). This alone should tell you that it is something that should not be attempted by users who are not professionals.

One user did ask in their forums if it was possible. Here's one response:

...to replace/upgrade/or modify those chips, we send them to factory. Precision soldering is required, it is not to be done at home (too fine a work for home, unless you have done this same exact work before and done it well everytime).

Even after factory re-work, some boards/assembly simply fail (shorted etc). Definitely not worth the risk unless you have direct access to a mother board assembly factory and someone does it for you over there.

Another user said:

In any case SMT chips as densely laid out as these are can't be desoldered and new ones desoldered by hand. You need very special gear only available at a fab house.

And a third user added:

They use a special fixture to hold the chips in place and heat both sides at the same time. Your chances is less than 20% getting it to work and heating the board without the proper masks could cause the other components to shift killing your system for sure...

Given that you can sell your (presumably functioning) existing machine for a fair amount of money, it seems like it would be much more practical to buy a new machine than take a very high chance of destroying your current one, since then it will be worth next to nothing.

|improve this answer
  • are these people referring to surface-mounted technology? – Janus Troelsen Nov 23 '14 at 11:32
  • I believe so, yes. – tubedogg Nov 23 '14 at 17:32
  • 1
    The new Airs also have a pathetic memory limit, though, so selling my existing Air and buying a new one doesn't really solve the problem, it just ameliorates it slightly. – iconoclast Nov 24 '14 at 15:59
16

Or is it massively more difficult to solder new memory into a laptop than it is to solder some simple electronics project?

Yes, it is; although "massively more difficult" is almost an understatement. It's an entirely different process.

Take a close look at the Macbook Air motherboard. The RAM chips are the four large components in the red box on the left side.

You'll notice first that there are no visible solder joints on these parts. This is because these parts are mounted to the motherboard using BGA technology — the solder joints are all on the underside of the chip. They cannot be attached using a soldering iron — they are typically attached using reflow soldering, which requires specialized hardware that you almost certainly do not have access to. Inspection of BGA joints is typically performed by X-ray… which you probably don't have access to either.

You'll notice as well that there are no available positions for additional chips. Assuming that Apple uses the same PCB design for the 4GB and 8GB models — which may not be the case! — you would likely have to remove the existing memory chips and replace them with compatible higher-capacity parts. This type of rework is extremely risky; the PCB is not designed to be reheated multiple times to remove and replace parts, and the heat cycles involved may damage the board, especially if inappropriate technique is used.

As if that weren't enough, it's not even clear the machine will recognize, or even be able to use, the new memory even if it is attached properly. Standard computer DIMMS contain a small EEPROM (the SPD chip) containing data on the type of the memory present, and the timings necessary to communicate with it. This part is not appear to be present on the Macbook Air; it's likely that the timing information is stored somewhere else in the system. Since this is not a user-serviceable part, there is no documentation available on where this data might be, nor how to update it to represent your new memory.

TL;DR: It's impossible. Not just difficult; seriously, it's impossible. If you need more memory, you'll need to replace the machine.

|improve this answer
  • I think it is typically stored in the same SPI flash chip where the UEFI firmware is stored. – Yuhong Bao Jun 7 '16 at 0:07
3

Here is video of changing memory chip on iPhone 6 with common hotair solder. It should be similar process and it does not look so impossible.. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2bGb5AOwp44

|improve this answer
  • cool, thanks. Given the claims others make of it being "impossible", can you offer any reason to believe that soldering memory in a MacBook would be the same as in an iPhone? – iconoclast Feb 17 '16 at 0:15
  • Before the publication of this video, I read the same comments about replacing the memory chips on the phone - it's not possible. Given that the flash chip from Samsung in iPhone is the same socket as RAM chip from hynix in macbook air, at least in my case (the same principle of pins with 0.7 mm distance) - technically this chip desoldering same principle applies. But I'm sure won't be the first one who will try it :) – Vlada Pulchart Feb 18 '16 at 20:18
1

It’s completely possible and not even that hard but you will need practice. No idea how they reset the bios to accept the ram though. I’ve desoldered bgas extensively the smaller they are the easier it is.

They get hard when they are bigger because if it’s huge you need a lot of heat. And you need to create profiles and have

|improve this answer
0

It's most likely because the difficulty (practical impossibility?) of getting RAM that is compatible and would fit inside the case. They don't use SO-DIMMs.

|improve this answer
-1

It is unfortunate that apple don't offer more memory as an option. But to replace it on your own, even if it is possible, is just stupid. Unless you are planning to start making similar upgrades for profit. But even then it's either to expensive or to risky. You can probably desolder the old chips and solder the new ones with a "relatively cheap" hot air desoldering station and home made heat shields. This however requires a lot of practice and luck. Even if you have done this several times you don't succeed every time. And even if you manage to create an ok connection to the chip you can't be sure the logic board accepts the new chip. If you want to pursue this I recommend buying a functioning macbook air logic board. Get four BGA-sockets of the right kind with pogo-pins for testing. And first make sure it works with the bigger modules. But then even if it accepts the larger memory, your success rate soldering is probably 1 in 10 so you'll end up working with one board for more than a day. And you are probably going to fry a logic board or two. If it was profitable/possible there would be some asian dude selling authentic MacBook Airs with more memory on Aliexpress.

|improve this answer
  • "If it was profitable/possible there would be some Asian dude selling authentic MacBook Airs with more memory on Aliexpress." Good point, Johan. – Mark Hubbard Jun 25 at 18:20
-7

RAM: Look in OWC to se if replacement memory for your MBA. If so you will find instructions on how to change it. SSD: same as before, for some models they have replacement SSD.

|improve this answer
  • 3
    OWC don't sell replacement RAM for any model of MacBook Air, because it's not possible for the user to replace it. – Mike Scott Feb 16 '16 at 21:29

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .