iPhone 4 running iOS 6.0.1.
I have Settings -> Music -> Shake to Shuffle turned off.
Without tapping the shuffle icon, if I select the first track on an album or a playlist, Music will not run through those tracks in start-to-finish order. It's always randomized in some way.
Needless to say, this makes listening to a "live" album fairly distracting...
Google has been no help, and other questions here get as far as "close, but not quite."
Am I missing a setting, somewhere?