Take the 2-minute tour ×
Ask Different is a question and answer site for power users of Apple hardware and software. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I own a macbook pro 17" late 2011 which has a 1920×1200 display with a pixel density of 132 ppi. Yesterday I tried hooking up the display to an Apple Thunderbolt Display, and to my great disappointment a window, when split across the two screens, was larger in the external Apple display than on the internal screen, due to the difference in the pixel density. I own a 24" HD display, and there I also notice the same issue.

I've spent some time researching, and I haven't been able to identify a potential candidate screen that has a display with comparable pixel density, and finally, size.

I see that some have suggested (in other questions) to lower the resolution on the internal screen, but that is, in my opinion, defeating the purpose of purchasing such a laptop and I would never consider such an idea.

Who can suggest displays, by any manufacturer, make and model, that are a good match as an external display for my MBP? The only condition I pose is that the display's resolution should be greater than the Macbook Pro's internal display resolution, as I see no advantage in using a second smaller screen.

share|improve this question

1 Answer 1

Unfortunately I think you're out of luck. The LCD panels that get put into computer displays are made by a relatively small number of companies. For various reasons (but primarily economies of scale) the manufacturers have settled onto a relatively small number of different panel sizes and resolutions (particularly at large resolutions), so it's pretty tough, if not impossible, to match pixel densities across different displays.

For resolutions higher than your MBP (1920x1200), there are really only two options on the market today:

  • 2560x1600 — used in 30" monitors, ~101 PPI
  • 2560x1440 — used in 27" monitors, ~109 PPI

Even if you go for a resolution around the same size as your MBP (1920x1200 or x1080), you can't get a similar density, as that resolution is typically only used in 21" - 24" external displays, resulting in PPI between 94 and 105.

The one device out there that does have a PPI close to your MBP is the non-retina iPad, which is pretty close to 132 PPI, but obviously you're giving up size and resolution there.

The next likely bump in resolution for desktop displays is probably going to be 3840x2160, which is 147 PPI in a 30" display, so still not that close.

You may find this page on Wikipedia informative.

share|improve this answer
    
I've reviewed that page on wikipedia quite a few times, and i spotted the ipad too, but as you say, it doesnt match the size. –  user436118 Dec 5 '12 at 17:03
    
I'm currently considering purchasing some replacement LCD panels for the Macbook Pro 17" and perhaps try to build something like this: cdn.baekdal.com/2008/macdual.jpg . I do have acess to a CNC mill and some other equipment, so it should be possible to build an enclosure to strap on to the mac. I'm just left wondering how to connect two LVDS displays to a macbook, and as I cant find a LVDS > Thunderbolt adapter I'm wondering if i'm out of luck ? –  user436118 Dec 5 '12 at 17:05
    
I don't know that much about LVDS or what sort of circuitry would be required to get a functional external display, but it will almost certainly require some soldering. I also know that the Displayport protocol can be used for internal displays as well, but I don't know if Apple does that or not. –  robmathers Dec 5 '12 at 17:28
    
Soldering isnt something that scares me. And apple will never make that, i wont even bother looking that up. I think I'll go down the matrox dual head thunderbolt -> dual dvi route , and mill some enclosures along with (possibly) something like this: axiomtek.com/products/ViewProduct.asp?view=809 –  user436118 Dec 5 '12 at 17:39

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.