Take the 2-minute tour ×
Ask Different is a question and answer site for power users of Apple hardware and software. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I have seen in shops that you can buy external Hard drives in both Windows and Mac format.

I was under the impression that an external Hard drive will work across both platforms, however having seen this and the fact that the Mac formatted one was £20 ($32) more expensive for the same capacity. I wanted to know what the difference is and what the benefits of a pre-formatted hard drive were.

share|improve this question
1  
Saves you from worrying how to spend an extra $5-10 –  XAleXOwnZX Mar 19 '12 at 23:23

7 Answers 7

up vote 13 down vote accepted

It's probably no different hardware-wise, just already formatted for the Mac. There's a whole pile of people who still think Macs need special everything, so the companies take advantage of that to fleece them out of an extra £20.

In general, you don't need special Mac-only hardware stuff anymore. Hard drives, RAM, peripherals, etc. are all fairly generally universally compatible; even the stuff that's generally seen as "Mac" (i.e., FireWire and now Thunderbolt) is Windows- and Linux-compatible and will generally work fine.

EDIT: I guess I can think of one good reason to buy a pre-formatted "Mac" drive: if the user is not someone who is comfortable formatting disks. On the other hand, Disk Utility is sufficiently straightforward I've walked my parents through formatting drives a couple of times over the phone, so I wouldn't waste the money.

share|improve this answer
3  
This is likely the case 99% of the time. External hard drive compatibility rests mostly on the file system (HFS+ for Mac, NTFS for Windows, EXT3 for Linux, etc.). Cross compatibility rests on the OS itself (and additional plugins). But sometimes, the units themselves, which carry proprietary firmware for the controller, may vary. Some WD external units don't play nice with OS X power settings (Mac's use the pmset utility to set things like HD spindown and sleep time). So while it may be just a case of petty "fleecing," it doesn't hurt to hit up Google and double check compatibility. –  cksum Mar 19 '12 at 23:13

You get the privilege of paying a bit more for the same thing to keep a Mac-friendly vendor alive.

This might be useful in terms of tech support: if you need to call someone who advertises "Mac formatted drives," you're probably more likely to get Mac-knowledgeable help.

share|improve this answer

I would add that sometimes the higher price comes from having on board firewire vs. USB connections. That's about the only reason I'd consider paying more for the hardware. Like @jaberg said - re-partitioning (as well as formatting) using Disk Utility is the way to go.

share|improve this answer

It's a dumb tax from the manufactures plain and simple. As mentioned above for anyone not comfortable with formatting their own drive.

Another thing to note FAT32 has file size limits (2GB per file) which is why if you're not comfortable with formatting a drive on OS X it might become an issue with the size of files some things create in OS X, video being the biggest culprit.

share|improve this answer

It is interesting to note that Hard Drive Manufacturers use the correct meaning of "Gigabytes" when referring to hard drives, and not what most people think of as a GB which is actually a Gibibyte:

  • Gigabyte = 10 to the 9 bytes = 1000000000bytes = 1000 megabytes

  • Gibibyte = 2 to the 30 bytes = 1073741824bytes = 1024 mebibytes

Since Mac OS X also switched to this "proper" definition for storage units such as Gigabytes as of Snow Leopard, then the size of the drive as mentioned on the box is more likely to be accurate when formatted for a Mac Partition than for a Windows Partition where your usable space seems "lower".

Note that all this is just so much technical drivel, your actual space available is the same on both, it's just that from a marketing perspective the given size will be correct on Mac as they have a common understanding of what a Gigabyte is, and incorrect on Windows which uses the commonly misused Gibibyte structure on it's filesystems whilst users incorrectly assume it is measures in Gigabytes.

Technically manufacturers should use GiB not GB when marketting and packaging their drives, but they don't/won't, and use Gigabyte which they know practically everyone uses incorrectly.

So, to make this a valid answer, the benefit is to know accurately the size of the drive you bought, and not have it magically shrink when you use it.

share|improve this answer

There is no benefit to purchasing a Macintosh formatted drive because it is trivial to reformat the drive yourself using Disk Utility.

  • Open Disk Utility.

  • Select your new disk from the panel on the left. Select the disk, not the partition which appears below it.

  • Click on the Partition tab on the right.

  • Important if you plan to use this as a bootable drive, select Options… (under the Partition Layout section) and choose a GUID partition map (assuming you're using Intel based Macs.)

  • Select the Format which is Mac OS Extended (Journaled) unless you know the specific reason why you're using something else. I would also leave the drive as a single partition unless you have a clear idea about why you're not doing so.

  • Click on Apply.

image if Disk Utility

share|improve this answer

None to any user who knows how to format it with Disk Utility. Its just a marketing method to justify a slightly higher cost. Now if you plan to plug it into a Airport Extreme as a external hard drive and don't have a Mac in the house to format it, then it has value.

share|improve this answer
    
I would be surprised if an AirPort didn't know how to read at least FAT32, if not NTFS. –  CajunLuke Mar 19 '12 at 23:18

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.