Take the 2-minute tour ×
Ask Different is a question and answer site for power users of Apple hardware and software. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I am using an external 2.5" hard drive (the original MacBook HD, which has been replaced by an SSD) in an Icy Box USB3 enclosure on my MacBook (running OSX Lion). When the MacBook goes to sleep, the activity led of the external hard disk gets on and you can hear a humming sound through the enclosure. This means there is some constant hard drive activity going on if the notebook is at sleep, which I find rather strange.

Does anyone experience a similar behaviour? Anyone know how I could fix this?

Maybe there are some people here that also use Icy Box enclosures for external drives, I'd be very interested if this is related to the enclosure?

Thanks for any hints.

share|improve this question
    
Might this be related to a "clamshell mode" setting? I don't know much about it but using a MacBook with the screen closed (to drive an external monitor) might keep various ports powered when they ordinarily might power down. Or, possibly the SSD has confused the energy saver setting that puts the HD to sleep when not in use. I realize this is an external but it's another piece of the puzzle to look at. –  Richard Nov 18 '11 at 11:44
    
I have a similar issue with Macbook Pro running Snow Leopard, with the ICY Box USB 3, it appears as though it may be related to the hardware then ? –  user19376 Feb 27 '12 at 9:54

2 Answers 2

A couple of questions that might shed some light on your subject:

  1. By chance, did you clone your HDD onto the SSD?
  2. If so, is your original OS X install still on the HDD?
  3. Are any of your active data files located on the HDD?
  4. Is the HDD activity constant or intermittent?

If (1&2) or 3 are true, the system on the SSD might be making calls to files on the HDD. This could be happening, especially if you didn't rename the HDD since your transplant. If 4 is constant, the activity cold be due to the USB 3 chipset attached via USB 2.

Here's a simple way to check:

  1. SSD to HDD calls:
    • Launch a program on the dock
    • Does the external HDD activity light start flashing as the program launches or shortly thereafter?
  2. Use your Mac "normally" for a while.
    • Close all obviously open data files.
    • Eject your external HDD by dragging the icon to the trash.
    • Does the OS show an error that it cannot eject the drive because files are open?
  3. HDD dependency
    • Shut down your MacBook.
    • Disconnect your HHD.
    • Reboot your Mac.
    • Run programs you don't expect to need anything from the HDD and watch for errors or "missing" data that could be attributable to an older data file.

If any of the above conditions happen, your Mac has open files on the external drive.

Compared with "old" operating systems, recent editions of OS X are rather advanced operating systems, especially when compared with our "archaic" notions of how computers work. Power constraints, most noticeable in notebooks and tablets, are the new target for today's advancements. Newer hardware is often "asleep" when we are actively using the computer--not just powering down the processor or video subsystem when it can. Today's systems shut down motherboard-level systems, like the network connection, whenever it can... sometimes even while we're surfing the net!

Today's Macs have what Apple calls "power nap". This is a sleep state where the computer "wakes up" portions of the system to download updates, make back ups, and other necessary system maintenance. Even if your MacBook doesn't fully support power nap, your MacBook is probably making periodic updates to various system files.

share|improve this answer
  1. It may be more a IcyBox related problem than a Mac OS related one. Have you tried a different enclosure?
  2. You could give http://www.stclairsoft.com/Jettison/ a try.
  3. And last but not least it may be a feature called "Power Nap", please see http://support.apple.com/kb/HT5394?viewlocale=en_US&locale=en_US - is your external drive your Time Machine backup location?
share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.